Comparison

Manual reconciliation or daily reconciliation with an agent?

An impartial, criterion-by-criterion comparison of Manual reconciliation and Daily reconciliation with an agent.

Comparison of Manual reconciliation and Daily reconciliation with an agent
Comparison of Manual reconciliation and Daily reconciliation with an agent
Comparison of Manual reconciliation and Daily reconciliation with an agent
In short

In manual reconciliation, someone opens the bank statement, the e-Invoice list and the ERP account movements side by side and matches them line by line; this usually piles up at month-end. With an agent, the three sources are matched every day and only unmatched records come to a person. If movements are few, doing it by hand is reasonable; as they grow, daily matching makes a difference.

Criterion-by-criterion comparison

Each row covers a single criterion.

Criterion Manual reconciliation Daily reconciliation with an agent
FrequencyUsually at month-end, sometimes weekly.Every day; the matched and unmatched lists are ready in the morning.
Who does itSomeone in accounting, with three screens open side by side.The agent matches; accounting looks only at the unmatched items.
Time calculationIf someone spends 2 days at every month-end, that is 24 days a year.Accounting looks only at exceptions; the time is proportional to the number of unmatched records.
When a difference is seenAt month-end; you work backwards to find the source.The next morning; the difference is found while it is still small.
MatchingDone by eye, looking at amount, date and description.Looks at amount, date, account name and invoice number; suggests partial and bulk payments as candidates.
ErrorsA line is skipped or the same record is matched twice; it may go unnoticed.The reason for every match is visible; an unclear record is never matched on its own.
ApprovalThe person who matched often approves it themselves.The agent matches and a person approves; the record is written to the ERP after approval.
SetupNone needed; the bank statement, invoice list and ERP report are enough.The bank, e-Invoice and ERP connections are set up; your ERP does not change.
When it is enoughIf monthly movements are few, you can carry on without any setup.It pays off with several accounts, many customers/suppliers and heavy daily movement.

Manual reconciliation suits you if

  • If you have only a few dozen bank movements a month.
  • If you work with a single bank and your e-Invoice volume is low.
  • If month-end matching does not hold up one person's work.

Daily reconciliation with an agent suits you if

  • If you work with several bank accounts and many customers/suppliers.
  • If going back to find the month-end difference eats your time.
  • If you want to know the collection and payment status every morning.

By hand when volume is small, daily as it grows

An agent is not a must for reconciliation. If you have a few dozen movements a month and month-end matching takes one afternoon, doing it by hand is the right call; the setup and connection effort will not pay off. As the number of accounts, customers/suppliers and daily movements grows, the picture changes: the difference shows up as a big pile at month-end and finding the source takes days. The agent clears that pile day by day, before it forms. It does the matching, leaves unclear records to you, and the closing approval stays with accounting. Your ERP does not change and your data does not leave the company; your team does not shrink, and accounting's work moves from matching lines to resolving exceptions. To know your own volume, tell us the number of movements and your month-end time; we will calculate it together.

Frequently asked questions about Manual reconciliation vs Daily reconciliation with an agent

Does the agent close the reconciliation on its own?

No. The agent matches and lists what does not match; the closing approval stays with accounting. An unclear record is never matched on its own, a person is asked.

Which sources does it match?

The bank statement, the e-Invoice list and the ERP account movements. It connects to your ERP only as far as the access you grant; setup is done on your own infrastructure.

Does daily reconciliation replace month-end reconciliation?

It does not remove it, it shortens it. Because differences are cleared day by day, the list to close at month-end gets shorter. Account reconciliation with the other party (e-Reconciliation) is a separate process.

See Manual reconciliation vs Daily reconciliation with an agent with your own data

Describe your process in a few sentences and we will show you the modules that fit.

  • 15+ years of enterprise software experience
  • In the cloud or on your own server
  • Processes compliant with KVKK (Turkey's data protection law)